Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
DTH News : Cable TV consumers can choose basic tier channels only from those on MSO network
MSOs only have to build capacity for 500 channels

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India on Friday asserted that the Tariff Order for Digital Addressable Systems (DAS) had not 'mandated' that multi-system operators (MSOs) must carry 500 television channels, but merely suggested they 'create the physical capacity' to be able to do so.

Meet Malhotra, senior counsel for TRAI :

He reiterated during the hearing challenging the Tariff Order that no revenue share had been kept for broadcasters in the basic service tier of Rs 100 for 100 television channels as they were free to air and it was only the MSOs who had to download them and retransmit them to the local cable operators. The revenue share therefore was decided in the ratio of 55:45. In the case of the bouquet of a mix of pay and FTA channels, the maximum rate prescribed was Rs 150 with a revenue sharing of 65:35 between MSOs and LCOs. The MSO would work out his own terms with the broadcaster.

He also said that carriage and placement fee had a place in conditional access system because of bandwidth constraints and since channels sought placement in prime bands, but there is no such constraint in DAS as all channels will be arranged genre wise.

Since digitization uses compression, more channels can be carried, which he described as 'optimal use of technology to bring a vast pool'. Carriage fee is also been removed as it creates needless competition, he added.

When he sought to argue that the law did not say anywhere that carriage would not be payable if the MSO approached the broadcaster, Navin Chawla who had represented Delhi Distribution Company intervened to say that that the 'must carry' made it mandatory for an MSO to get a channel that the subscriber asked for.

He added that the Statement of Objects and Reasons to the amendment of the Cable TV Networks (Regulation) Act 1995 itself had referred to creating a basic service tier and was not something that TRAI had thought of on its own.

Furthermore, he said that the law was clear that pay channels could be brought in by TRAI into its tiers if the Central Government was satisfied.

He also supported TRAI's stand in its defence of the 2010 Tariff Order, which TDSAT had struck down and against which TRAI's appeal was pending in the Supreme Court. He said that the wholesale price at which broadcasters and MSOs were now agreeing was in the range of Rs twenty.

Referring to constant comparisons to direct-to-home, he said the Cable Act did not cover DTH. There was therefore no logic in claims of similar revenue.Referring to the argument that there was no reference to broadcaster in the BST or the upper tier, he said even the licences given to DTH platforms did not have any mention to the broadcaster as the two worked out their own revenue sharing. In fact, he claimed that DTH was shaky in the face of DAS and the operators were therefore offering all kinds of incentives.

Malhotra said there appeared to be 'too much transparency for the stakeholders to handle' in the Tariff Order. But he said that the Tariff should be allowed to work for some time and TRAI and the Government would themselves make changes if they are considered necessary.

When he claimed that some pan-Indian MSOs had already accepted the Tariff Order, counsel C S Vaidyanathan who had represented Digicable said these belonged to broadcasters.

Malhotra will conclude his arguments on 17 September.

Earlier, counsel Soumitra Ghose Chaudhuri on behalf of LCO Udaya Shankar Roy Chowdhury claimed that LCOs would also have to spend huge sums to upgrade their systems just as the MSOs had to do. This upgradation would work out to about Rs 1500 per subscriber, whereas the Tariff Order gave only Rs 45 in the BST.

In the higher tariff of Rs 150, the LCO and MSO stand to lose even more money if a subscriber chose to take only pay channels and no FTA channels.


Thanks given by:
Cable TV consumers can choose basic tier channels only from those on MSO network

Cable TV consumers will be able to choose the 100 television channels as part of the basic service tier of free-to-air (FTA) channels only from those available with their multi-system operators (MSOs).

This was stated by Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai) senior counsel Meet Malhotra while making arguments against petitions challenging the regulator's Tariff Order, allaying fears of MSOs and local cables operators that they will have to make available any and every channel demanded by their consumers.

Malhotra said the Tariff Order allowed the consumer a choice of opting for any 100 FTA channels from the network of the MSO 'in lieu' of the 100-channel package offered by the MSO.

For more Click Here.

Thanks given by:

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  General News: Punjab govt likely to charge Rs 50 as entertainment tax per cable TV, DTH connection nairrk 0 852 07-31-2017, 10:10 AM
Last Post: nairrk
  General News: Cable, DTH to attract lower taxes under GST nairrk 0 859 05-23-2017, 04:02 PM
Last Post: nairrk
  Breaking News: Flipkart tops consumer study, most preferred e-commerce platform among consumers rahul1117_kumar 0 665 07-01-2016, 02:53 PM
Last Post: rahul1117_kumar
  Network of 21 labs against Swine flu ABCD10 0 603 03-17-2015, 09:43 PM
Last Post: ABCD10
  DTH News: Govt gives 15 days grace for phase II cable TV digitisation waytobala 1 1,532 04-03-2013, 06:02 PM
Last Post: Sathish
  Update: Samsung Smart TV viewers to access over 70 HD quality Indian channels waytobala 0 4,709 01-18-2013, 01:40 PM
Last Post: waytobala
  Update: HRD Ministry seeks licences for 50 educational DTH channels waytobala 0 970 12-20-2012, 01:39 PM
Last Post: waytobala
  Breaking News: Media Pro deactivates Asianet channels in Kerala waytobala 3 1,638 11-24-2012, 07:30 PM
Last Post: MAHI
  Update: NDTV brings two international channels to India waytobala 0 1,428 11-21-2012, 02:31 PM
Last Post: waytobala
  DTH News: English movie channels to start phase-wise switch off on analogue cable waytobala 5 1,719 10-11-2012, 12:13 PM
Last Post: waytobala

Forum Jump:

Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)